What is Agency of Record (AOR)?

This guide explores the long used term "Agency of Record" including its multi-decade evolution, past and present day usage, and how it applies to current and future business and marketing needs.

 

What does an Agency of Record do?

An Agency of Record serves as the client's main strategic and creative partner, handling various tasks such as:

• Brand Strategy
• Market Research
• Overall Brand Management
• Creative Strategy
• Creative Execution
• Developing Advertising Campaigns
• Media Planning and Buying
• Brand and Marketing Campaign Analytics

Origination of the AOR Term and Title

The term "agency of record" has been in use since the early to mid-20th century.

During this time, the advertising industry and concept of an agency as a business grew rapidly and became more structured. As a means of protecting both the client and agency, agencies began establishing long-term contractual relationships with clients. Within these relationships, agencies would agree to handle various aspects of the clients branding and marketing needs.

The designation of an agency as the client's agency of record was a way to formalize this exclusive or preferred relationship.

 

How the Agency of Record Role has Evolved

Since its inception, the term has remained relatively consistent and is still being used today. The role of an Agency of Record, however, has evolved dramatically since its early usage.

The main changes we've experienced in the AOR role reflect the changing dynamics of the marketing industry. The AOR's role has shifted from being a one-stop-shop to a strategic partner, leveraging data and working in tandem with in-house teams to deliver effective and integrated marketing solutions.

We took a trip down memory land and spent time reviewing the most notable changes to AORs over the past 30 years:

Shift towards Specialization

In the past, AORs were typically full-service agencies that handled various aspects of a client's marketing needs. However, with the rise of digital marketing, specialized agencies focusing on specific areas such as social media, content marketing, or search engine optimization emerged.

Somewhere around 2010, clients began seeking specialized expertise and started working with multiple agencies to meet their diverse marketing requirements.

This shift led to the AOR role evolving to accommodate collaboration with specialized agencies, creating a more integrated and flexible approach to marketing campaigns.

Emphasis on Data and Analytics

Along with the rise of emerging media channels came a surge of advanced data analytics tools and technologies. This shift created a fast growing emphasis on data-driven decision-making in marketing.

The AOR role adapted with this surge and evolved to incorporate data and analytics capabilities into their services. Agencies now play a crucial role in collecting, analyzing, and deriving insights from consumer data, allowing for more targeted and personalized marketing strategies.

The most dramatic shift we experienced from this evolution was the changing focus from creative intuition alone to a more data-informed approach.  

Collaboration and Integration with In-House Teams

Recently, many brands have established or expanded their in-house marketing teams to have greater control and agility over their marketing efforts.

This has led to yet another shift in the AOR role, with agencies increasingly working in collaboration with in-house teams.

AORs now act as strategic partners, complementing and integrating with in-house resources to drive marketing initiatives. This collaborative approach allows for a more seamless alignment of brand vision, expertise sharing, and faster execution. Agencies are increasingly expected to work closely with in-house teams to ensure consistency, efficiency, and mutual success.

How Hiring an Agency of Record Benefits the Brand or Client

Hiring an AOR can provide substantial benefits to the hiring brand. Engaging the right partner can enhance the brand's marketing effectiveness, provide strategic guidance, ensure consistency, and optimize resource allocation.

Let's walk through four specific advantages of hiring an Agency of Record:

Comprehensive Expertise 

AORs typically have a diverse team of professionals with specialized skills across various marketing disciplines. The agency will bring a wealth of knowledge and experience to the table, covering areas such as brand strategy development, creative design, media planning and buying, market research, and more.

This comprehensive expertise allows the Agency of Record to provide holistic and integrated solutions, ensuring that all aspects of the brand's marketing efforts are effectively coordinated and executed.

Consistency and Continuity

By designating an AOR, a brand establishes a long-term relationship and fosters continuity in its marketing efforts. This consistency is valuable for maintaining a cohesive brand identity and ensuring that messaging and visuals align with your audience across different campaigns and channels.

Over time, your Agency of Record becomes deeply familiar with your brand's values, any rebranding process, target audiences, and objectives, resulting in more coherent and impactful marketing initiatives.

Strategic Partnership

A strong AOR relationship goes beyond executing marketing tasks. The agency becomes a strategic partner, working closely with the brand to understand its business goals, market landscape, and competitive positioning.

The AOR can offer valuable insights, identify opportunities, and develop tailored strategies that align with the brand's objectives. This collaborative approach enhances the brand's marketing effectiveness and helps drive business growth.

Cost and Resource Efficiency

Engaging an AOR can be a cost-effective solution compared to maintaining an in-house marketing team or working with multiple agencies for different marketing functions. AORs often offer comprehensive service packages at a more competitive rate, streamlining the budgeting process and providing access to a full range of marketing expertise. Additionally, brands can save on internal resource allocation by leveraging the AOR's capabilities, allowing them to focus on core business operations.

What are the Disadvantages of Hiring an AOR?

Hiring an AOR can bring numerous benefits, but there are also potential disadvantages to consider. While these disadvantages exist, they may not be applicable or significant in every situation so it's crucial to assess your brand's specific needs, goals, and resources before deciding whether an AOR relationship is the best choice for your marketing strategy.

Lack of Specialization

AORs typically offer a wide range of services to cater to various marketing needs. However, they may not excel in every specific area.

If your brand requires highly specialized expertise in a particular niche or industry, an AOR's generalized approach may not be as effective as working with a specialized agency that focuses solely on that area.

Potential Lack of Agility

AORs often work on long-term contracts or retainer agreements, which can result in a less flexible working relationship. If your brand requires rapid adaptation to market changes or the ability to pivot quickly in response to emerging trends, the structure of an AOR arrangement may not provide the necessary agility. Some brands may prefer more project-based collaborations that allow for greater flexibility and faster turnarounds.

Limited Fresh Perspectives

While AORs offer continuity and consistency, there is a potential risk of stagnation or lack of fresh ideas. Over time, an AOR might become overly familiar with your brand, leading to a creative plateau. Without regular infusion of new perspectives, there is a chance that campaigns and strategies may become predictable or fail to break new ground.

It's important for brands to actively foster an environment that encourages innovation and seek out fresh insights, whether through collaboration with other agencies or engaging in ideation sessions.

Reliance on a Single Partner

When you designate an AOR, you become heavily reliant on that agency for all your marketing needs. If the AOR faces internal challenges or a decline in quality or service, it could impact your entire marketing function. Additionally, should the business relationship deteriorate or not meet your expectations, it can be challenging to switch to a new agency quickly, especially if you are bound by long-term contracts. The decision to hire an AOR should be carefully considered, ensuring that the agency's capabilities, culture, and track record align closely with your brand's vision and requirements.

Benefits of Becoming an Agency of Record to the Agency

Long-Term Revenue Stability

When an agency is designated as an AOR, it typically involves a long-term contractual relationship with the client. This arrangement provides a stable source of revenue for the agency, as it secures ongoing work and a consistent stream of projects from the client. By becoming an AOR, agencies can minimize revenue fluctuations and have a more predictable income, allowing them to plan and allocate resources more effectively.

Deeper Client Relationships

Being an AOR fosters a deeper and more intimate relationship with the client. The agency becomes the client's trusted partner and advisor, intimately involved in their brand, marketing strategies, and goals. This close relationship enables the agency to better understand the client's needs, anticipate challenges, and provide tailored solutions. The agency can build a strong rapport and trust, leading to greater collaboration and mutual success.

Increased Influence and Control

As an AOR, the agency gains more influence and control over the client's marketing initiatives. They become the primary driver of strategy, creative direction, and execution. This increased level of responsibility allows the agency to have a more significant impact on the client's brand and marketing outcomes. It also provides an opportunity for the agency to showcase its expertise, creativity, and effectiveness, further solidifying its reputation and positioning in the industry.

Operational Efficiencies

Serving as an AOR often involves managing a broader range of the client's marketing activities. This consolidated approach allows the agency to achieve operational efficiencies. They can streamline processes, leverage shared resources, and develop a deep understanding of the client's industry and target audience. By having a comprehensive understanding of the client's marketing landscape, the agency can deliver integrated and cohesive campaigns, maximizing the effectiveness of their strategies and initiatives.

Disadvantages of becoming an AOR for Agencies

While becoming an agency of record (AOR) can offer several advantages, there are also potential disadvantages to consider. Here are four disadvantages of being an AOR:

Limited Revenue Diversification

As an AOR, your agency may become heavily reliant on a single client for a significant portion of its revenue. This dependency on a single client can pose serious financial risks if the client reduces their marketing budget, decides to switch agencies, or faces financial difficulties.

A sudden loss of the AOR status can have a substantial impact on your agency's financial stability and growth if you don't have a diversified portfolio of active clients/revenue.

Increased Client Expectations

Being designated as an AOR often leads to higher client expectations. Clients may place greater demands on the agency, expecting exceptional performance, innovative ideas, and quick turnarounds. Meeting these elevated expectations consistently can be challenging and may require additional resources, talent, and time investments from the agency.

Limited Flexibility and Autonomy

As an AOR, you may have less flexibility and autonomy in decision-making compared to working on a project-by-project basis.

The long-term contractual nature of the AOR relationship may limit your ability to take on other clients or pursue opportunities outside the scope of the AOR arrangement.

This lack of flexibility may hinder your agency's ability to explore new markets, work with diverse clients, or adapt quickly to changing industry trends.

Potential Creative Constraints

While being an AOR allows for deeper understanding of the client's brand and objectives, it may also involve creative constraints.

Your agency may need to align its creative output closely with the client's preferences, brand guidelines, or established marketing strategies. This can limit creative freedom and experimentation, potentially impeding the agency's ability to showcase its full creative potential.

 

What is the future of the AOR role?

Predicting the future shifts in the agency of record (AOR) role can be challenging due to the dynamic nature of the marketing industry. However, based on current trends and emerging developments, here are three potential shifts that could shape the AOR role in the next 10 years:

Increased Emphasis on Automation and AI

The advancement of automation and artificial intelligence (AI) technologies is expected to have a significant impact on the AOR role. AI-driven tools and platforms can streamline processes, automate repetitive tasks, and provide valuable data insights. AORs are likely to adopt and leverage these technologies to enhance campaign optimization, audience targeting, and real-time analytics. This shift may allow AORs to focus more on strategy, creative innovation, and leveraging AI to drive more personalized and impactful marketing experiences.

Integration of Emerging Technologies

The next decade is expected to witness the widespread adoption of emerging technologies such as augmented reality (AR), virtual reality (VR), and voice assistants. AORs will need to stay abreast of these technologies and find innovative ways to integrate them into their clients' marketing strategies. Whether it's creating immersive AR/VR experiences, optimizing content for voice search, or leveraging new platforms, AORs will be tasked with understanding and harnessing the potential of these technologies to deliver engaging and effective brand experiences.

Focus on Purpose-Driven Marketing

Consumers are increasingly demanding that brands take a stand on social and environmental issues. In response, brands are incorporating purpose-driven marketing into their strategies, aligning themselves with causes and values that resonate with their target audience. AORs will likely play a pivotal role in helping brands define their purpose and develop authentic and impactful purpose-driven campaigns.

AORs will need to understand the evolving consumer landscape, guide brands in ethical decision-making, and create campaigns that effectively communicate a brand's purpose and drive positive change.

The Top 3 Agency of Record in 2023

Yes, this list (or any list for that matter) can be subjective. We offer the list in hopes it will help you or someone source the right AOR for you needs. As such, we've specifically listed a breadth of agency sizes and capabilities.

1. Ogilvy

Founded in 1850 by Edmund Mather, Ogilvy is one of the largest, and longest standing advertising agencies today. Ogilvy's agency service offering is broken into brand strategy, advertising, customer engagement and commerce, public relations and influence, digital transformation, and partnerships.

Pro's of working with Ogilvy:

• Breadth of industry and geographic capability
• Full-service offerings across multiple functions
• Strong, seamless customer interaction across internal functions

Cons of working with Ogilvy:

• Limited access for small and medium brands
• Ogilvy focuses on a small amount of very large corporate and brand relationships that make it hard or unlikely that small brands can gain access.
• Bad press associations from working with socially objectionable clients, such as tobacco companies and U.S. Customs and Border Protection

2. MAGNETIC

Founded in 2006, MAGNETIC works within a diverse range of clients budget ranges across the globe. MAGNETIC's agency service offering consists of brand strategy, brand development, full suite creative services, growth marketing, and analytics.

Pro's of working with MAGNETIC

• More accessible to range of business sizes (SMB to Enterprise)
• Data-led brand, creative and marketing helps businesses set and achieve meaningful goals
• Progressive growth marketing and analytics tactics

Con's of Working with MAGNETIC

• Not niche specific
• Does not offer public relation services
• Currently operates in the United States and South Africa

3. Grey

Grey is among the top advertising agencies in the world and serves one-fifth of the FORTUNE 500 companies. The agency worked hard for years to be named Adweek’s Global Agency of the Year in 2013 and 2015. Grey has over 6,500 employees in 432 offices around the globe.

Pro's of working with Grey

• Strong history of working with large brands
• Part of larger advertising group, AKQA
• Geographical placement of offices enables multi-national access and production

Con's of working with Grey

• Limited access for small and medium brands
• Company size and corporate structure can produce constraints on smaller detailed workloads

*The agencies included on this list have not paid for placement. If you are interested in being added to this list, please reach out to hello@mag.cr.

 

We're here to help

We hope this guide has been helpful in understanding Agency of Record and in your search for the right partner. Please reach to us with any questions or for help in your search.